Menu Icon Legend

MONDAY GOURMET SOUP

Bowl of soup is served with Hearth Bread or Asiago Cheese Bread.
Yukon Gold Potato Cheddar 
$3.89+
Vegetarian SW Roasted Corn 
$3.89+
French Onion 
$3.89+
Broccoli Cheddar 
$3.89+
Chicken Noodle 
$3.89+
Clam Chowder 
$3.99+
Classic Chili 
$3.99+

TUESDAY GOURMET SOUP

Bowl of soup is served with Hearth Bread or Asiago Cheese Bread.
Vegetarian Roasted Red Pepper with Gouda 
$3.89+
Loaded Baked Potato 
$3.89+
Vegetarian Country Vegetable 
$3.89+
French Onion 
$3.89+
Broccoli Cheddar 
$3.89+
Cream of Chicken Wild Rice 
$3.89+
Lobster Bisque 
$3.99+
Chicken Chili 
$3.99+

WEDNESDAY GOURMET SOUP

Bowl of soup is served with Hearth Bread or Asiago Cheese Bread.
Twice Baked Potato 
$3.89+
Vegetable Beef Barley 
$3.89+
Broccoli Cheddar 
$3.89+
Chicken Noodle 
$3.89+
Cheesy Chicken Tortilla 
$3.89+
Classic Chili 
$3.99+
Clam Chowder 
$3.99+
Vegetarian Black Bean  
$3.89+

THURSDAY GOURMET SOUP

Bowl of soup is served with Hearth Bread or Asiago Cheese Bread.
Yukon Gold Potato Cheddar 
$3.89+
Vegetarian SW Roasted Corn 
$3.89+
Lasagna Soup 
$3.89+
Broccoli Cheddar 
$3.89+
Cream of Chicken Wild Rice 
$3.89+
Baja Chicken Enchilada  
$3.89+
Lobster Bisque 
$3.99+
Chicken Chili 
$3.99+

FRIDAY GOURMET SOUP

Bowl of soup is served with Hearth Bread or Asiago Cheese Bread.
Loaded Baked Potato 
$3.89+
Roasted Red Pepper with Gouda 
$3.89+
French Onion 
$3.89+
Broccoli Cheddar 
$3.89+
Chicken Noodle 
$3.89+
Cheesy Chicken Tortilla 
$3.89+
Classic Chili 
$3.99+
Clam Chowder 
$3.99+

SATURDAY GOURMET SOUP

Bowl of soup is served with Hearth Bread or Asiago Cheese Bread.
Loaded Baked Potato 
$3.89+
French Onion 
$3.89+
Broccoli Cheddar 
$3.89+
Cream of Chicken Wild Rice 
$3.89+
Classic Chili 
$3.99+
Clam Chowder 
$3.99+
Country Vegetable with Grilled Vegetables 
$3.89+
Wisconsin Beer Cheese 
$3.89+

ITALIAN SANDWICHES

All sandwiches can be made into a wrap. The wrap flavors we offer are jalapeño cheddar, tomato basil, whole wheat, or garlic & herb. You can make a “lighter” sandwich by having it made with our low-fat mayo.
Numero Uno 
Smoked ham, Genoa salami, prosciutto, provolone cheese, tomatoes, onions, lettuce and herbed olive oil dressing.
$7.99+
Italian B.L.T. 
Pickerman’s classic interpretation with grilled Capicola, lettuce, tomatoes and mayonnaise.
$7.99+
Meatball 
Grilled meatballs simmered in a rich Parmesan marinara sauce with melted provolone cheese.
$7.99+
That's Italian 
Italian-style roasted peppers and melted provolone cheese top a delicious prosciutto, ham and salami sandwich with our olive oil dressing.
$7.99+
Italian Beef 
Marinated Italian beef, Giardiniera peppers, and a side of au jus.
$8.99+

TRADITIONAL SANDWICHES

All sandwiches can be made into a wrap. The wrap flavors we offer are jalapeño cheddar, tomato basil, whole wheat, or garlic & herb. You can make a “lighter” sandwich by having it made with our low-fat mayo.
Ham & Swiss 
Premium hickory-smoked ham and melted Swiss cheese with lettuce, tomatoes and onions, served with our herbed olive oil dressing.
$7.99+
Roast Beef 
Premium roast beef with melted provolone cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, sweet red onions and our special bistro sauce.
$8.99+
Classic Club 
Hickory-smoked ham, grilled capicola and smoked turkey with lettuce, tomatoes and mayonnaise. A Pickerman’s Original!
$7.99+
Texas Barbecue 
Hickory-smoked beef brisket chopped and simmered in a tangy barbecue sauce and topped off with dill pickle slices.
$8.99+
Vegetarian 
Our homemade dill cream cheese topped with cucumbers, marinated tomatoes, green peppers, sweet red onions and olive oil dressing.
$6.99+
Smoked Turkey 
Hardwood smoked turkey breast slices, lettuce, tomatoes, sweet red onions and our special dressing.
$7.99+
Roasted Chicken Breast 
Lean all-white grilled chicken with melted Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomatoes and mayonnaise.
$7.99+
Tuna 
All-white albacore tuna salad with lettuce, tomatoes and sweet red onion.
$6.99+
Lamb Gyro 
Lamb gyro meat, red onions, diced tomatoes, shredded lettuce, and a side of tzatziki sauce.
$7.99+
Pastrami Sandwich 
Thinly-sliced pastrami, Swiss cheese, dill pickles, and Düsseldorf Mustard served on a marble rye.
$8.99+
Chicken Chipotle Sandwich 
Roasted chicken breast, cheddar cheese, onion, tomatoes, lettuce, mayo, and Ancho chipotle dressing.
$7.99+
Egg Salad Sandwich 
Our homemade egg salad, with green peppers, and lettuce.
$6.99+
Chicken Salad Sandwich 
With green peppers, sliced tomatoes, and iceberg shredded lettuce.
$7.99+
Corned Beef Sandwich 
Served with Thousand Island dressing, tomato, and lettuce.
$8.99+
Grilled Cheese 
$6.59+

SALADS
Classic Caesar Salad 
Fresh lettuce and Asiago cheese, garnished with seasoned croutons. Served with a rich Caesar dressing.
$7.99+
Chicken Caesar Salad 
Our classic Caesar salad with a generous portion of grilled chicken breast.
$9.49+
Greek Salad 
Lettuce, crumbled feta cheese, Kalamata olives (watch out for those pits), tomatoes, onions and pepperoncini, served with a zesty Greek dressing. A favorite!
$7.99+
Garden Salad 
Lettuce, tomatoes, green peppers, onions, cucumbers and seasoned croutons.
$7.99+
Chicken Pecan Salad 
Lettuce, sliced tomatoes, iceberg lettuce, shredded mild cheddar, diced capicola, carrots, red cabbage, and pecans.
$9.49+
Oriental Salad 
Chopped lettuce mix, Mandarin oranges, red onions, chow mein noodles, almond slices and Oriental dressing.
$7.99+

COMPLEMENTS
Potato Salad 
$1.89
Pasta Salad 
$1.89
Chips 
$1.89
Asiago Cheese Bread 
$1.89
Hearth Bread 
$1.89
Pickle Spear 
$0.49

DESSERTS & COOKIES
Cheesecake 
$2.99
Scotcharoo Bars 
$1.19
Brownie (with Walnuts) 
$1.89
Chocolate Chip Cookie 
$1.19
M&M Cookie 
$1.19
Oatmeal Raisin Cookie 
$1.19
Peanut Butter Cookie 
$1.19
Double Chocolate Chip Cookie 
$1.19
Sugar Cookie 
$1.19

BEVERAGES
Fountain Drink 
Fri. 05-03-2024, Patrick (Pat) Paul Weinberger: Please change Fuze unsweetened tea option under fountain drink to raspberry tea.
$2.69
Soda (Bottled) 
$2.69
Soda (Can) 
$1.69
Bottled Water 
$2.69
Monster Energy Drink 
$2.99
Diet Monster Energy Drink 
$2.99
Zero Calorie Vitamin Water 
$2.99
Snapple Juices 
$2.99
Sprechers Root Beer 
$2.99
Sprechers Cream Soda 
$2.99
Sprechers Orange Soda 
$2.99
Sprechers Cherry Soda 
$2.99

CATERING

Let Pickerman’s cater your next event! Choose from sandwich trays, box lunches, salads, soups, sides, and desserts. To ensure premium quality, freshness and taste, our catered sandwiches are served cold. Please place all catering orders one day in advance if possible. Where possible, please try to order at least 2 hours in advance.
Sandwich Trays 
$39.00+
Potato Salad 
$39.00+
Pasta Salad 
$39.00+
Greek Salad 
$39.00+
Caesar Salad 
$39.00+
Chicken Caesar Salad 
$45.00+
Garden Salad 
$39.00+
Chicken Pecan 
$45.00+
Oriental Salad 
$39.00+
Boxed Lunch 
$12.99
Dessert Tray 
Assortment of cookies, brownies (with walnuts), and scotcharoo bars.
$13.00
Brownie (with Walnuts) Tray 
A dozen brownies made with walnuts.
$18.00
Dessert Tray 
Assortment of brownies (with walnuts), scotcharoos, and cookies.
$13.00
Assorted Cookie Tray 
Reese's peanut butter, chocolate chip, M&M, sugar, oatmeal raisin, and double chocolate chip cookies.
$13.00
Your cart is empty.
Accepts Google Pay
Accepts Venmo
Loading, please wait.